CN defends safety record in face of three train derailments within a month

GAINFORD, Alta. – CN Rail is defending its safety record after three high-profile derailments involving trains carrying hazardous materials within the space of a month while apologizing for the latest mishap.

Thirteen cars on a CN (TSX:CNR) freight train carrying a cargo of oil and liquefied petroleum gas went off the rails near the tiny hamlet of Gainford, about 80 kilometres west of Edmonton, early Saturday morning.

There were two explosions reported and the community was evacuated as a precaution.

The situation was so volatile that firefighters simply backed off and let the fire burn itself out. They estimated it could take at least 24 hours for that to happen and told a news conference late Saturday that it could be up to 72 hours before residents could return to their homes.

Saturday’s mishap occurred two days after residents in the Alberta community of Sexsmith were forced from their homes when four CN rail cars carrying anhydrous ammonia left the rails. That followed the derailment of 17 CN rail cars, some carrying petroleum, ethanol and chemicals, in western Saskatchewan on Sept. 25.

There were no injuries in any of the derailments.

Despite the cluster of derailments, a CN spokesman said rail remains a safe way to transport materials.

”CN’s safety record has been very solid, in terms of its main track derailments last year, they were the lowest on record,” said company spokesman Mark Hallman.

”The vast majority of commodities, such as dangerous commodities, that are transported from origin to destination, more than 99 per cent reach destination without any accidental release.”

Federal New Democrat MP Olivia Chow took issue with that assessment. She called on the federal government to take stronger action to improve rail safety.

”The latest train derailment, fire and evacuation tell the Conservative government that vague promise without a clear work plan is not enough,” Chow said in an email.

She said inspections need to be increased and automatic braking systems need to be mandated. Municipalities also need to be given better information about what dangerous goods are being transported on trains.

Federal Transport Minister Lisa Raitt’s office issued a statement saying the federal government has invested over $100 million in rail safety and brought in tougher fines for companies that violate safety regulations.

Three of the rail cars on the train that derailed Saturday caught fire. They were carrying liquefied petroleum gas. Four freight cars carrying crude didn’t break open, Hallman said.

CN said the train was travelling to Vancouver from Edmonton.

The Gainford area remained under a state of emergency Saturday night. Travel on the Yellowhead Highway – the main east-west corridor in northern Alberta – was restricted.

The Transportation Safety Board was sending investigators to the scene to determine the cause of the derailment.

In a statement, CN said the track was tested last week as well as last month and no issues were found. It also said an inspection of the train when it left Edmonton on Friday found no problems.

CN was clearly sensitive to the public relations fallout from the derailment. The company brought in some of its top brass to manage the situation, including Chief Operating Officer Jim Vena.

He apologized to the residents of Gainford for the disruption and promised the company would get to the bottom of what happened to prevent it from happening again.

”We run a safe railroad, but we do have incidents,” Vena said.

The recent derailments come as documents obtained by Greenpeace suggest CN is considering shipping Alberta bitumen to Prince Rupert, B.C. in quantities matching the controversial North Gateway pipeline.

A departmental briefing note obtained under access to information laws said CN was reportedly working with Chinese-owned oil giant Nexen to examine transporting crude by rail to be loaded onto tankers for export to Asia.

CN denied it made a specific proposal for Prince Rupert, but said it will consider any such project as it comes up.

The Northern Gateway project has faced intense scrutiny and criticism and it was unclear whether the project would get the necessary approval.

There has also been intense scrutiny over shipping oil by rail following July’s horrific derailment of a Montreal, Maine and Atlantic train in Lac-Megantic, Que. The subsequent fire claimed 47 lives.

Photo: Derailed CN #railcars near #Gainford Alberta #YEG http://t.co/CX502PfBSr

— TSB of Canada (@TSBCanada) October 20, 2013

NEW IMAGE: Air photo from the train derailment near #Gainford, Alta pic.twitter.com/Q0W4nvAaLM – @CTVEdmonton

— Simon Ostler (@SimonOstler) October 19, 2013

Evacuated #Alberta village left livestock behind after derailment: mayor. About 100 people out of #Gainford homes, fire still burning.

— CBC News Alerts (@CBCAlerts) October 20, 2013

#Gainford residents should contact their insurer about additional living expenses due to train derailment evacuation.

— IBC (@InsuranceBureau) October 20, 2013

 Saturday October 20: Parkland County (Alberta) Fire Chief James Phelan media briefing

Photo: Planned controlled vent and burn of rail car product #Gainford #Alberta http://t.co/vxW32ufkft

— TSB of Canada (@TSBCanada) October 21, 2013